In light of Dave Grohl’s recent admission about infidelity, we’re reminded that cheating can happen in any relationship, regardless of how strong your relationship seems to be. The emotional aftermath can linger for months or even years, and yet, as hard as it seems, a relationship can survive infidelity—and in some cases, emerge stronger.
As a Couples Therapist and Sexologist, I’ve worked with many couples navigating the complex journey after cheating. Here, I’ll explore:
For the partner who has been cheated on, any reason for infidelity will likely never fully make sense or bring comfort. We often ask ourselves “but why?” as if discovering the reason might help us finally understand or prevent the pain from happening again. The truth is, no explanation will ever justify your partner’s actions or undo the hurt you’re feeling. It’s important to know that cheating isn’t always a reflection of the relationship or the person who was betrayed. Infidelity is a complex issue, driven by a variety of emotional, relational, and situational factors. Knowing some of these reasons can support you on the road to healing.
Many affairs start as emotional connections. When someone feels emotionally disconnected or misunderstood by their partner, they may seek out others to fulfill those unmet needs. Emotional affairs can be just as painful as physical ones. [1].
Research suggests that dissatisfaction with physical intimacy is a common reason for infidelity [2]. When sexual needs aren’t being met, some may look outside the relationship to fill that gap.
Ongoing conflicts and unresolved issues can create a rift between partners. Infidelity often stems from feeling unloved or angry within the relationship, leading to longer-lasting affairs and relationship breakdowns [4].
In dating relationships, personal dissatisfaction or uncertainty about whether their partner is “the one” can drive someone to cheat. This often reflects a need for self-discovery or validation. Situational factors and impulse: Stress, intoxication, or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time can lead to impulsive decisions [5].
Long-term relationships can experience a decline in passion over time. Some individuals may cheat to regain a sense of excitement or novelty that they feel is missing from their lives [1].
Those struggling with self-worth may turn to infidelity to feel desired or important again. Some people cheat as a way to seek external validation when they feel inadequate in their relationship [1].
It’s natural to want certainty after experiencing infidelity, and the phrase “once a cheater, always a cheater” can feel like an easy answer. It’s a black-and-white response that aims to protect you from being hurt again.
But the truth is more nuanced.
While some individuals are more likely to repeat infidelity, many won’t cheat again.
Understanding the reasons behind cheating and the research on repeat behaviour helps shed light on this.
Individuals with traits like narcissism, impulsivity, or avoidant attachment styles are more likely to cheat again. These traits make it difficult to form and maintain deep emotional connections, increasing the risk of repeat infidelity (6, 7).
Some individuals are at risk of becoming serial cheaters, especially if they don’t address the underlying reasons for their infidelity. Research shows that people who cheat in one relationship may cheat in subsequent ones, but this isn’t universal. Many people stop once they’ve worked through the problems that led to the infidelity (6, 9).
Not everyone who cheats does so repeatedly. Many people cheat because of temporary stress, emotional disconnection, or a moment of poor judgment. Once those situational factors are addressed, they are less likely to cheat again (8).
The quality of a relationship plays a critical role in whether infidelity happens again. When the issues that led to cheating—like unresolved conflict or ongoing dissatisfaction—are left unaddressed, the risk of repeating the behaviour is higher (6). However, research shows that when couples work to improve their relationship, either through therapy or open communication, the chances of infidelity happening again significantly decrease. Addressing emotional disconnection and dissatisfaction can help rebuild trust and prevent future cheating (7, 8). In fact, couples who take steps to resolve their underlying issues are far less likely to face repeat infidelity (9).
Many individuals who cheat feel deep remorse and take steps to change their behaviour. Through therapy and personal growth, they can address the factors that led to infidelity and significantly reduce the likelihood of it happening again (7, 10).
Ultimately, while some people are more prone to repeat behaviour, many won’t cheat again—especially if they take responsibility and address the underlying causes of their actions. Whether someone cheats again often depends on their willingness to do the work needed to change.
Recovering from infidelity requires commitment from both partners.
It’s important to understand that this is not a quick process—healing will unfold in stages, and it may take many months or even longer for trust and intimacy to be fully restored. As much as you may want to move on quickly, it’s essential to address all aspects of the betrayal, the emotions that follow, and the problems within the relationship itself.
Couples Therapy can play a crucial role in expediting the healing journey, helping both partners navigate the pain and uncover the underlying issues that led to the infidelity.
As someone who has worked with hundreds of couples in my practice, I’ve seen firsthand how challenging—but also transformative—this journey can be. My approach to helping couples heal from infidelity is rooted in well-established, research-backed methods like the Gottman Method and Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT). These approaches focus on addressing the pain of betrayal, rebuilding emotional bonds, and restoring trust.
The cheating partner must take full responsibility and acknowledge the deep hurt they’ve caused, while the betrayed partner should be encouraged to express their feelings openly and honestly. This process is essential for creating an environment of empathy and understanding. The relationship can’t move forward without full remorse from the cheating partner.
The partner who cheated must be willing to be fully open, sharing details that can help their partner understand what happened, and being transparent about their whereabouts, intentions, and actions moving forward. This can feel restrictive to the partner who cheated, who may feel like their privacy is being invaded, but it’s a necessary step in restoring trust. It’s not a permanent state—it’s part of the healing process to atone for what happened and create safety for the betrayed partner.
Sweeping the affair under the rug and deciding to “move on” without addressing it will only cause more harm in the long term. Honest communication (without attack) is crucial for repairing emotional bonds. Both partners need to build better communication tools and learn to openly discuss their feelings, the betrayal, and their relationship.
Infidelity often stems from deeper issues in the relationship, whether that’s emotional disconnection, unmet needs, or unresolved conflicts. Couples need to work on these root problems if they want to prevent future betrayals and build a stronger relationship. Therapy can help facilitate conversations about these deeper issues, allowing you to gain clarity about what led to the affair and how they can work through it together.
Trust isn’t rebuilt overnight—it’s restored through small, consistent actions over time. The partner who cheated must show consistent transparency, openness, and emotional availability, demonstrating their commitment to restoring trust. Equally important, the betrayed partner needs to be able to express their fears and emotions openly and be met with understanding and empathy. Rebuilding emotional connection means reconnecting on a deeper level—through vulnerable conversations, emotional support, and showing up for each other even when it feels hard – which it often will.
Sexual intimacy after infidelity can vary greatly between couples. For some, sexual connection might return quickly, while for others, it may represent a deeper layer of vulnerability that takes more time. It’s important to talk openly about boundaries and desires, ensuring both partners feel safe and respected. Starting with small gestures, like non-sexual touch or spending quiet time together, can help ease the path back to deeper physical closeness.
The pain of infidelity is deep, and in the immediate aftermath, it’s natural to wonder whether your relationship can ever fully recover.
Over the past 15 years of working with couples, I’ve seen firsthand that relationships can move forward after infidelity. In many cases, couples who take the time to deal with the affair—and the deeper issues that may have contributed to it—end up with stronger, more resilient relationships.
Infidelity often forces couples to confront issues they may have been avoiding for years, such as emotional disconnection, communication breakdowns, or unmet needs. In doing so, you not only repair the damage caused by the affair but also build a foundation that’s healthier and more secure than before.
Healing from infidelity involves more than just moving past the affair. It requires rebuilding trust, repairing emotional connection, and creating new patterns of intimacy and communication. The experience of working through the pain together can foster your resilience, greater empathy, and a renewed commitment to each other.
But I can’t promise you this will be easy.
This is a difficult journey – but so is the alternative: breaking up.
The short answer is: yes, many relationships do heal from infidelity, and some even become stronger than before—but it takes significant time, effort, and commitment from both partners.
References
